THE CRAVE GAMING CHANNEL
V'lanna
 






Affiliates
AnimeBooks
AnimeNation
GameMusic.com
Play-Asia.com

R P G A M E R . C O M   - R O U N D T A B L E

Independent vs. Franchise
!
!



Liv: In the future, would you rather see more games from franchises or independent games? In addition, how do you think companies feel about this issue?

Jesus: Well, I think what we need are some new franchises.

Jesus: No one seems to be looking for the next big thing.

Derek: I'd prefer a bit of each, really.

Michael: Well, it's safer for companies to make games in established franchises, but I think we tend to get more creative titles with individual games.

Michael: If it's one or the other, give me stand-alone titles.

Jesus: This isn't just RPGs, but the whole gaming industry is overly reliant on sequels.

Derek: it's nice to have new stuff, but I'd also like more of what is already established as working

Jesus: Michael - Oh, of course.

Liv: I would agree. Heck, even the movie industry now is overly focused on sequels.

Jesus: But even these franchises were once new.

Michael: Guh. The movie industry. Don't get me started. :/

Jesus: Liv - The game industry is worse than the movie industry in that regard.

Michael: Jesus - Nah, I disagree.

Jesus: I mean, the game industry will slap a franchise name on ANYTHING.

Jesus: Which is what I was trying to talk about before.

Jesus: I mean, does Phantasy Star really need to be made into a dungeon hack?

Jesus: And an FF shooting game?

Josh: Heh.

Derek: Poor Shining......

* Liv will agree with this. ^^;

Josh: I'm happy with independent games...sometimes they just deliver quality without having to worry about whether they're going to screw it up later.

* Josh points at Okami.

Jesus: Hehe, true.

Jesus: A good standalone is fun.

* Liv points at Boku to Maoh (Okage).

Liv: I love that game. =)

Jesus: The problem is that a game will come out, but unless it's a franchise, there's no marketing for it.

Josh: Okage? :(

Jesus: Hehe, too true.

Michael: It's got good art direction, but I'd love to stab whoever designed those dungeons.

Liv: Yeah, Okage: Shadow King.

Jesus: Michael - That bad...

Josh: I know what it is, I'm boggled as to how you like it

Derek: Yeah.....those urns....

Liv: I just loved how the story was sooooo different, but I agree with the dungeon thing...

Michael: How to smash ten thousand pots!

Liv: That was annoying. ^^;

Michael: I've started that game four times already... >.>

Josh: And the battles take half an hour due to excessive spell casting time.

Liv: But Ruka was the cutest hero ever!!

Jesus: And then there's FFXI....

Jesus: One of the most generic MMOs ever.

Josh: Guild Wars is a great franchise...unfortunately, it's rather overshadowed by WoW.

Jesus: Well, everything is overshadowed by WOW.

Michael: So is every other MMO right now. :/

Liv: I've heard a lot of good things about Guild Wars, but I've never played it.

Jesus: Michael - Indeed.

Jesus: It's funny, but the only MMO that non-MMOers can name other than WoW is FFXI.

Jesus: Which is probably because of the FF name.

Michael: It's another similar situation - one 800 pound gorilla dominating the market.

Derek: ^^;

Jesus: Michael - Only in MMOs, it's even more apparent.

Jesus: Half the market plays WoW.

Jesus: The rest are scattered to the winds.

Michael: Yeah. How many subscribers are they claiming now? 5 million? 7?

Michael: Lots, anyway.

Jesus: I think it hit 7, yeah.

Jesus: That's bigger than some 3rd-world countries, I think.

Michael: Which is why I'm surprised to hear about all these little Korean MMOs doing so well.

Michael: You'd think there wouldn't be room for 'em.

Jesus: Michael - Well every game will find a niche.

Liv: They're so much fun!

Josh: Well, most Korean MMOs are level grinding...just with cute characters.

* Liv enjoys the cute characters...

Liv: =)

Michael: Heh.

Josh: But, I mean...hardcore level grinding. As in, nothing else to do.

Jesus: Josh - Well most MMOs are just level grinding, period.

Michael: Well, a good sense of style goes a long way. ^^

Derek: Yeah. =/

Josh: RO - What was the point of THAT game?

Jesus: To level, basically.

Josh: Exactly.

Liv: What's RO?

Liv: Oh...

Josh: Ragnarok Online

Liv: I remember now.

Jesus: Ragnarok Online.

Derek: Ragnarok Online.

Liv: XD

Jesus: Hehe.

Jesus: But WoW is another example of the dangers of franchise dominance.

Liv: What do you think companies feel about designing franchise games as opposed to independent games?

Jesus: Other devs are scared to make MMOs because of it.

Jesus: Liv - Well the publishers probably see it as easy money.

Derek: Indeed.

Michael: Yeah, there's been very little innovation in MMOs lately, probably due to WoW's dominance.

Jesus: Michael - Which is weird to me.

Michael: Weird how?

Jesus: If I wanted to play something that's just like WoW, wouldn't I just play WoW?

Jesus: MMOs aren't like other RPGs.

Jesus: They require a near fanatical dedication to do well in.

Jesus: And ask that you stay for months at a time, if not years.

Jesus: If you're trying to pull people out of the game they've been playing for a year or more, wouldn't you wanna offer something different to intice people away?

Liv: I would agree with that philosophy, lol.

Jesus: Wow, thought I'd netsplit for a sec.

Jesus: Um, looks like we're done, unless someone's got something else to say...

Liv: Alright, yeah, I was just going to say something.

Jesus: Oh?

Liv: Does anyone else have any last comments they'd like to add in?

* Jesus is interested.

Jesus: Hehe, well I do.

Liv: Ahaha, it was nothing intriguing.

Derek: Not I.

Liv: Said the fox.

Jesus: If you wanna see something other than FF derivitives, buy other stuff!

Michael: Heheh.

Liv: I agree!

* Derek too.

Jesus: I'm sure Nintendo will publish some non-FFy RPGs if Baten Kaitos Origins does well.

Liv: Alright, and with thaaaaat...

Liv: We shall be done~!

Liv: Thanks everyone!

Josh: Allrighty

Jesus: Done we are.

<< 1 2



© 1998-2008 RPGamer All Rights Reserved
Privacy Policy