Criterium	Carlisle	Barieuph	RedBeastMage	Total Score
Theme	10	8	8	26
Creativity	35	39	42	116
Remix	25	25	27	77
Production	12	15	14	41
Total	86	79	87	260

Comments

Barieuph

Theme - I gave you an eight because you did a great job of picking source material from a game that is "unsung" if you will. However, I hold two points against you for choosing the final boss music. 

Remix - I like the remix and the middle section really added a lot to the mix, and saved you from the "transcription" fate that we all get caught up in when writing.

Creativity - I like what you've done here, using the styles of other groups and it really shows your mastery of the instrumentation. 

Production - No complaints here, the sound quality is great. 

Redbeastmage

Theme - Very nice choice of source material. Loses a bit for being final boss music that, to me, stuck out as memorable. But as the character's theme, I never really though about it like that, and it had alot of merit.

Remix - Very recognizable theme music, quickly noticed by anyone who has played through the game. Liberty taken with the melody, without ever feeling like it has departed too far from the source.

Creativity - The style is very fitting for the piece. The guitar solo near the end is really stunning, and the gem of this piece. The bass keeps the piece moving along, and gives the guitar a lot of freedom to move about and play with the melody.

Production - Very well put together. I think the drums needed a little something, as the kick just didn't pack enough, uh, kick. The bass is solid, and the guitar is amazing.