Submit an Arrangement | Soundtrack Review Template | Contact the Curator | Guidelines
Update Archive | Soundtrack Review Archive | Submission Archive
The Grand Audition 2009
Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 | Final Round
Dragon Lord, Teepo The Sinned Knight
Comments and Score Breakdown
Criterion Fermat's Last Theorem Macstorm Ish Judges' Subtotal Readers Readers' Subtotal Total
Theme 3 2 5 1.67 4.32 2.16 3.83
Remix 25 27 28 13.33 24.91 12.46 25.79
Creativity 27 30 35 15.33 27.55 13.77 29.11
Production 7 10 10 4.5 6.91 3.45 7.95
Total 62 69 78 34.83 63.68 31.84 66.67
66.67 - Third Place
Discuss this round's results in the RPGamer Forums.

Fermat's Last Theorem: The main problem with the mix is its inability to stand apart from the original. I didn't perceive any instrumentation changes and the music itself was virtually unchanged. The samples utilized did improve the overall sound of the piece, particularly the pseudo-brasswind synth that carried the melody. A little shuffling of segments or the addition of a secondary theme wouldn't have hurt. All in all, it's not a bad mix. It simply pales in comparison to the other entries for this round.

Macstorm: Overall, a solid remix, but one that does not really differentiate itself from the original piece. While a great effort, it doesn't do enough new to make itself stand out. I have to give credit for using a lesser known piece, though, even if Breath of Fire 3 didn't fit the theme quite right.

Ish: No comments.

   « Back   
© 1998-2015 RPGamer All Rights Reserved
Privacy Policy