THE CRAVE GAMING CHANNEL
V'lanna
 






Affiliates
extralife
metacritic
AnimeBooks
AnimeNation
GameMusic.com
Play-Asia.com

R P G A M E R . C O M   -   E D I T O R I A L S

Controversy Sells - But Who's Buying?
!
!

Mike "JuMeSyn" Moehnke
FAN EDITORIALIST



Politics is a great bugaboo in the context of RPGs - or any video games, for that matter. Understandably so, for a mention of politics tends to throw the player out of the game world and back into an unpleasantly real world. Aside from an occasional NPC conversation courtesy of a very liberal translation, politics tends to stay out of the RPG world. Yet there is no reason for the status quo to remain thus indefinitely, and the option of including political influences bears the distinct appeal of never having been tried.

It should be understood what I am NOT suggesting here by treading into the dangerous ground of political content. An RPG that goes out of its way to include material of a highly topical nature runs the real risk of becoming outmoded in a few years, and such a result is to be avoided at all cost. Direct slurs against specific persons run a different risk, that of legal action. I also do not espouse one political view only - it is quite possible with a bit of flexibility in the story to have a player experience events according to his or her own desires instead of as dictated by The Almighty Programmers. Political commentary also should not dominate the proceedings to such a degree as to overshadow all other developments: i.e. the protagonist should not devote his/her life towards the creation of a universal pension plan or a way to enact a flat tax. Politics can be a part of the experience, not the whole.

An RPG with firm political dealings would most likely not be created in Japan. The Japanese political climate is very different from that which exists in North America, and North America is itself divided between the United States and Canada. If Bio Ware is to create an RPG with political content, will it be directed at Stephen Harper or George W. Bush? A Japanese-developed title of this sort would most likely exhort or decry Junichiro Koizumi, until he steps down later within a year. A grave difficulty awaiting an RPG tied to national political infrastructure is the parochial nature of its story; can RPGamers in, say, Australia be made to care overmuch about events dealing intricately with the British Parliament? This reinforces my earlier observation that politics cannot dominate the proceedings, for its doing so will limit potential audiences to a specific nationality. A title trying to incorporate features extant in more than one country is a possibility, but prone to stretching too far and collapsing. There is also the chance of politicians seeing visages of themselves in video games as being the stimulus required for even more virulent anti-gaming measures than already exist.

The inclusion of political content in an RPG must therefore be carefully dealt with. How it might be accomplished would vary according to individual developer preference, but some potential options I will delineate. By far the most obvious would seem to be the casting of major villains in the mould of certain real-life political figures; precisely who these figures ought to be is best left for each reader to determine. This most obvious of avenues is flanked by other potential methods, however. Using real political dilemmas without any clouding of the issue in an RPG context seems a good fit; what of a scenario in which the player must combat a legislature forever mired in calling its members names instead of actually accomplishing something? Or a scenario in which the player must deal with a drug-abusing substratum of the population - possibly because these people are chronic informants to the enemy in order to garner cash for their addictions, the precise reason to deal with them can be specified at another time. The issue of censorship in an RPG context - something such as a government agency and/or a superior in whatever organization the characters happen to be associated with trying to shut down potentially harmful information by claiming it disastrous to the public - and its ramifications could potentially be quite thought-provoking.

That this is an issue requiring the utmost sensitivity in being dealt with I cannot refute. Politics by its very nature polarizes, and if a title is created carelessly it could have the disastrous side effect of polarizing the interactions between RPGamers in a noxious fashion akin to what takes place on any given cable channel talking-head 'debate.' The dreaded topic of religion is treated in RPGs from time to time, however, albeit often in a fashion obfuscating its controversy by creating a religion that does not exist on Earth. RPGs are prone to the best storylines in the video game world, and politics allows for great story possibilities if nothing else.




Discuss this editorial on the message board
© 1998-2012 RPGamer All Rights Reserved
Privacy Policy